Quite possibly a luddite.

  • 1 Post
  • 251 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 10th, 2023

help-circle








  • I think it’s not so difficult to understand the appeal, of course for those deeply religious who long back to Zion, but also to those who just long for a home country. I know old secular Jews who, before all this bullshit, was considering moving to Tel Aviv for their retirement because it felt more like home to them then the US, despite being American all their lives and despite being politically progressive and very much not on the Bibi side of things.

    It’s a complicated situation now - on one hand I think it’s crucial that Jews should not feel the need to be apologetic or to constantly have to emphasize that they don’t represent a government they have nothing to do with. If that becomes the standard we’re already lost. On the other hand, people might need to hear it in order to understand Netanyahu is not some supreme leader of the unified Jews of the world, as too many people seem eager to believe.


  • I have to admit I’ve had this approach taking to Israelites for a while - I never felt comfortable in a conversation before having some sort of an indication of their political leaning. Israelites seem to often have a way of talking about things without talking about things, which usually makes it clear pretty quickly where they stand. I guess they also often feel a need to place themselves.

    As for Jewish people living outside of Israel, I think the fact that they’ve all had a standing invitation to move to Israel and opted not to make use of it speaks for itself. Sure there are Bibi supporters, but that goes for Christians as well.

    Still I see where you’re coming from of course. And I find it freaking terrifying to be honest.


  • This is what I don’t get here. Why the hell do people interpret this as if it’s spreading Israeli propaganda?

    We know Hamas killed substantial number of innocent people and are keeping hostages.

    We know these hostages are kept somewhere in Gaza.

    We know Israel is bombing the shit out of Gaza, actively destroying civilian infrastructure.

    What we learn from this is that Israel has indeed killed hostages in their indiscriminate bombing, that Hamas seem to be keeping hostages alive when they are not killed by Israeli bombs, and that being held hostage by Hamas in Gaza is still an awful situation to be in.

    If this makes Hamas look bad it’s because they are bad.

    If you think it makes Israel look good you’re sick in the head - this is triggered by them intentionally bombing Gaza until there’s nothing left.

    If you’re upset that it makes a Jewish person look human then fuck right off you worthless piece of shit.






  • A lot of Israelis are blaming Netanyahu for the war, the Supreme Court of Israel struck down his constitutional reform, and thanks to him Israel can no longer take the support of their oldest allies completely for granted. The relationship between the US and Israel was already at an all-time low before all this thanks to Netanyahu being a piece of shit.

    Of course, there’s also the flip side of the coin: Netanyahu has always had a fear based platform, and the political climate lends itself well to that at the moment. There’s always a rally behind the flag effect, and elections are still far away. So even if he loses the next election in a landslide that might be too late. Frankly it has been too late for many years already.

    So all in all I agree in not being incredibly optimistic.





  • It’s not exactly a deserted wasteland - it’s not that easy to find somewhere to dump 170m tons of mining waste without affecting some ecosystem or another.

    The fjords are pretty and symbolically nice, but the fact is that as long as there’s a demand for minerals, they have to be dug from somewhere, and ecosystems are going to be affected by it. Moving the problem somewhere else doesn’t solve anything.

    It reminds me of that time we needed rocks for road construction in Norway, and we had decided all the mountains in the region were too precious to be destroyed for that kind of purpose. So we ended up buying vast quantities stones from China rather than using locally sourced products. Which is great - that way they can fuck up their nature instead.

    If we don’t want mining we just have to stop consuming. Moving problems out of sight doesn’t solve anything.